100 South St, Greenport, NY 11944 (631) 333-2200
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

Come join us! 

#summer2021

631-333-2200


  • a plate of food on a table
    Slide 1 of 5
  • a plate of food on a table
    Slide 2 of 5
  • a plate of food on a wooden table
    Slide 3 of 5
  • a plate of food on a wooden table
    Slide 4 of 5
  • a plate of food on a table
    Slide 5 of 5

    • Lunch & Dinner specials denoted in (parenthesis) 

    thursdays are FOOTBALL !

    Check for specials there on Thursdays !!!


    #cometogether #summer2021

    Seasonal Delights

    • Sauteed Corn & Shrimp Salad

      Pan seared shrimp, spinach, watermelon & feta, corn salad; red onion, mango, pineapple, jalapeno, lime

      $26

    • Maine Mussels

      Maine Mussels

      White wine, garlic, butter, toasted baguette

      $18

    • Lobster Roll

      Lobster Roll

      5oz lobster, green goddess herb butter, frisee, split top potato bun, First Fries

      $36

    • B.L.T.

      Heirloom tomato, applewood smoked bacon, sourdough, chipotle aioli, First fries

      $19

    • Paella (dinner)

      Pan seared shrimp, chicken, chorizo, mussels, smoked paprika, vegetable arborio rice, hand crushed tomato, lemon zest, spring peas

      $34

    • Frisee Calamari

      lightly fried artichokes & hearts of palm, mesclun greens, sweetie drop & banana peppers, lemon garlic aioli

      $24

    • Lobster Mac n Cheese

      5oz lobster, old bay spice, fresh herbs, house cheese blend

      $36

    • Fish Sandwich

      Blackened branzino, lemon garlic aioli, lettuce, tomato, first fries

      $25

    • Steak Frites (Dinner)

      6oz Skirt Steak, house BBQ, First fries

      $28

    Farm Fresh Sides

    Dessert

  • a plate of food on a wooden table
    Slide 1 of 4
  • a cup of coffee on a table
    Slide 2 of 4
  • a plate of food on a table
    Slide 3 of 4
  • a person holding a plate of food on a wooden table
    Slide 4 of 4

    • This menu is available OPEN to CLOSE (except Sundays for BRUNCH)

    Lunch specials & Dinner specials also available.

    TO GO ORDER? We may have limited availability due to in-house dining. We'll do our best to accommodate you! 

    Call us 631-333-2200 or 631-333-2201 to place an order. 

    Please have a credit card ready when you place your order, even if you pay cash we require a credit card to place your order! Thank you!

    Snacks & Starters

    • Cheese, Meat & Pickle Plate

      Cheese, Meat & Pickle Plate

      Triple creme brie, truffle cheddar, prosciutto, cornichon, marcona almonds, quince paste, crostini

      $24

    • Bread Service

      Baguette with house herb butter

      $5

    • Wings

      Wings

      Choose from our dry rub chipotle, dry rub ranch or classic cajun buffalo

      8 wings $18

    • Shishito Peppers

      Shishito Peppers

      Sauteed in olive oil, finished with smoked sea salt, lemon zest, old bay aioli

      $13

    • First Fries

      First Fries

      hand cut, triple blanched idaho potatoes served with house made ketchup

      $10

    • Cheese Fries

      Cheese Fries

      Housemade fries, all the cheese

      $14

    • Dirty Fries

      Dirty Fries

      first fries, pulled pork, black beans, sweetie drop & banana peppers, chipotle aioli

      Dirty Fries $25

    Soups & Salads

    • South Street Chowder

      South Street Chowder

      Our classic chowder; littleneck clam, applewood smoked bacon, cream, potato (gf)

      Pint $12

    • House Salad

      House Salad

      Mixed lettuces, watermelon radish, tomato, cucumber, dijon red wine vinaigrette

      $12

    • Blue Cheese Salad

      Blue Cheese Salad

      spinach, tomato, carrots, avocado, radish, croutons, blue cheese dressing

      $18

    • Rice & Beet

      Rice & Beet

      fried chickpeas, yellow & red beets, goat cheese, wilted spinach, dried cranberries, balsamic, olive oil

      $24

    • Kale Caesar Salad

      Kale Caesar Salad

      Baby kale, house caesar dressing, garlic croutons, sliced apple

      $16

    Classics Menu

    A few usual suspects.
    • Mac & Cheese

      Mac & Cheese

      Classic Mac and Cheese. Add some fun mix ins or enjoy as is.

      For One, may be two :) $18

      Add Mushroom & Truffle Oil $6

      Add Applewood Smoked Bacon $6

      Add Spinach $4

      Gluten Free Pasta $4

    • Fried Chicken Sandwich

      Fried Chicken Sandwich

      Buttermilk Chicken Breast, lettuce tomato, first fries

      Regular $19

      Add honey & hot sauce $23

      add bacon and goat cheese ranch $23

      add whole grain honey mustard, pickles & slaw $23

    • Ahi Tuna Burger

      Ahi Tuna Burger

      House ground Ahi tuna, pan seared, sesame, carrot & ginger slaw, avocado citrus cream, first fries

      $24

    • Black Bean Burger

      Black Bean Burger

      Roasted yellow peppers, queso fresco, chipotle aioli, green salad GF available

      $18.50

    • Mojo Pulled Pork Sandwich

      Pickled cabbage slaw, house-made smokey house bbq, banana peppers, queso fresco, first fries

      $21

    • Really Good Burger

      Really Good Burger

      Lettuce, First Fries, Pickle Toppings: fried egg 3 cheddar 2 gruyere 2.5 blue cheese 2.5 avocado 4.5 applewood smoked bacon 3.5 grilled onions 2.5 mushrooms 3 crispy fried onions 3.5 gluten free bun 4

      $15

  • a bowl of food on a plate
    Slide 1 of 8
  • a close up of a sandwich sitting on top of a table
    Slide 2 of 8
  • a person holding a wine glass on a table
    Slide 3 of 8
  • a person sitting at a table with a plate of food
    Slide 4 of 8
  • a plate of food on a wooden table
    Slide 5 of 8
  • a bowl of food on a table
    Slide 6 of 8
  • a chicken sandwich and fries on a plate
    Slide 7 of 8
  • a close up of a sandwich sitting on top of a wooden table
    Slide 8 of 8

    • Brunch Specials will vary between Saturday & Sunday 

    #eatdrinkplay #findyourway #greenport #2021


     

    Saturday 11am & Sunday 10am

    • Parfait (Sunday only)

      Strawberries, vanilla greek yogurt, house granola, fig jam

      $10

    • Pop Tart (baked Sunday's only)

      Made in house, fresh fruit filling

      $5

    • Monte Cristo (sundays only)

      ‘egg dipped ham sandwich’ our way prosciutto, gruyere, two fried eggs, challah French toast, green salad, honey mustard

      $22

    • Roasted Tomato Tart (Sunday only)

      1760 Homestead Farms tomatoes, fresh eggs, blended cheeses, matzo crust, green salad

      $15

    • Lobster Roll

      5oz lobster, green goddess herb butter, frisee, split top potato bun, First Fries

      $36

    • First Fries for two

      Hash Browns?? Who needs 'em? Share some fries with a friend!!!!

      $10

    • Calamari Salad

      fried artichokes & shishitos, banana peppers, mixed greens, lemon garlic aioli

      $24

    More brunch

    • French Toast

      Brioche bread, strawberries, fresh whipped cream, maple syrup

      $15

    • "Put an Egg on It"

      Dirty Fries (vegetarian or bacon & pulled pork) plus 2 poached eggs

      $25

    • Frittata

      Fresh baked crust less quiche, Vegetarian~ spanish, plum tomato, house cheeses, jalapeño, green salad

      $16

    • Avocado Toast

      sourdough, cherry tomatoes, citrus oil, fried chick peas, balsamic drizzle, green salad

      $18

    • BLT

      applewood smoked bacon, sourdough, lathams’s lettuce & heirloom tomato, cornichon aioli, green salad

      $21

    • Mussels

      butter, white wine, toasted baguette

      $18

  • a plate of food
    Slide 1 of 4
  • a close up of food on a wooden table
    Slide 2 of 4
  • a plate of food and a cup of coffee
    Slide 3 of 4
  • a piece of cake on a plate
    Slide 4 of 4

    • Cocktails

    • Aperol Spritz

      prosecco, aperol, club soda, orange

      $11

    • Huckleberry Lemonade

      44 north huckleberry vodka, mint, house lemonade

      $11

    • Old Fashioned

      Jeffersons Small Batch bourbon, black cherry, orange, sugar in the raw, bitters

      $12

    • Margarita

      sliver tequila, fresh lime, agave, triple sec

      $11

    • Peach Iced Tea

      4 roses bourbon, peach nectar, fresh lemon, unsweetened tea

      $10

    • “The Mule”

      fresh lime, ginger beer texas: titos vodka smoked: el buho mezcal

      $10

    • Boris & Natasha

      rosé, figenza vodka, st. germain, fresh lemon, club soda

      $13

    • Mimosa

      oj, prosecco

      $10

    • Bloody Mary

      pickled vegetables, titos vodka, house mix

      $11

    • The Fancy

      LIV vanilla vodka, cold brew, chocolate, leopold brothers french press coffee liqueur, cream, fresh whip & a cherry on top

      $12

    • Dark and Stormy

      Ginger beer, Goslings rum, Lime

      $10

    Wine

    by the glass available but why stop there, buy a bottle

    • Prosecco, Ca’ De Doge

      Italy, NV

      Glass $10

      Bottle $35

    • Brut Sparkling Pointe

      North Fork, 2015

      Bottle $58

    • One Woman Sauvignon Blanc

      North Fork, Long Island

      Bottle $35

    • Sauvignon Blanc Tablelands

      Martinborough, NZ

      Bottle $35

    • Macari Estate Chardonnay

      100% stainless steel, Apple, pear

      Glass $14

      Bottle $52

    • Merlot Mccall Vineyards

      North Fork

      Glass $11

      Bottle $42

    • Matthew Fritz Cabernet Sauvignon

      California

      Glass $12

      Bottle $44

    Beers

    • Miller Lite

      $5

    • Stella Artois

      $6

    • Corona

      $6

    • Allagash White

      $6

    • Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

      $6

    • AleWife

      Death to Ego IPA or Thousand Stars Pilsner

      $8

    • Barrier Brewing Company

      Seasonal Fresh Can

      $8

    • Glutenberg Pale Ale

      Gluten Free

      $7

    • Clausthaler NA Beer

      $6

    • Cigar City Maduro Brown

      $7

    • Austin East Orange Cider

      $6

    Soft Drinks…

    • Wicked Mint

      mint, lime bitters, grapefruit, simple syrup, club soda

      $6

    • Peach Punch

      black cherry, peach nectar, lemon, club soda

      $6

    • Mineral Water

      $6 per 750 ML

    • San Pelligrino Limonata

      $4

    • Coca-Cola

      $3

    • Diet Coke

      $3

    • Sprite

      $3

    • Gingerale

      $3

    • Unsweetened Iced Tea

      $3

    • Lemonade

      $3

    • Root Beer

      $4

    • Cream Soda

      $4

    • Apple Juice

      $3

    • Kombucha

      Passion Fruit

      $5

  • bar
    Slide 1 of 6
  • a glass of wine
    Slide 2 of 6
  • a cup of coffee on a table
    Slide 3 of 6
  • brunch
    Slide 4 of 6
  • bourbon, rye cocktails
    Slide 5 of 6
  • a person holding a wine glass
    Slide 6 of 6

    • All of our desserts are hand made & full of love. 

    • Seasonal Fruit Crisp

      select fruits, almonds, oat streusel, vanilla bean ice cream

      $11

    • Oatmeal Pie

      Oatmeal Pie

      Sweet custard & brown sugar pie, fresh whip

      $10

    • Fruit Tart

      Fruit Tart

      Gluten Free crust, seasonal fruit, fresh whip

      $11

    • Brownie Sundae

      Brownie Sundae

      Tahini brownie bites (gf), toasted sesame, vanilla ice cream, caramel, chocolate sauce, fresh whip, amaro cherries

      $14

    • Mascarpone Cheesecake

      Mascarpone Cheesecake

      seasonal fruit compote, graham cracker crust

      $11

    • Mango Sorbet

      $8

    • Dark Chocolate Mousse

      Blood orange compote, fresh whip

      $12

  • a plate of food on a table
    Slide 1 of 3
  • a person sitting at a table with a plate of food
    Slide 2 of 3
  • a person sitting at a table with a plate of food
    Slide 3 of 3

    • Every Thursday....

    Tiki Thursdays ~ dreamy drinks, pig roast, tiki tacos and pad thai 4 - 9pm  #eatdrinkplay #tiki #cornhole #findyourway #firstandsouth #greenport #northfork #newyork #longisland #tikithursday🌴🧉 📸 @dyoungphoto #thankyou #pigroast #tikitacos #padthai #tunatacos #freshfood #eatlocal

    Drinks

    • Mai-Tai

      Aged Puerto Rican & light Barbados rums, Cointreau, Orgeat, mint

      $15

    • Lorikeet

      Rhye whiskey, banana, cinnamon, peach, peychauds bitters

      $15

    • Chuka-Chuka

      Monkey in Paradise Vodka, pineapple, dark cacao, honey, coconut

      $15

    • Tropical Itch

      Barbados & dark Jamaican rums, mango, triple sec, angostura

      $15

    • Island Famous

      Overproof white Jamaican & Brazilian rum, aperol, green chartreuse

      $15

    • Dead Head

      Dark Barbados & light Jamaican rums, grapefruit, absinthe, grenadine

      $15

    Tiki Eats

    • Pad Thai

      Traditional sweet & sour, lime, cilantro, mung beans, fried tofu (YUM), rice noodles, sriracha

      $21

      Grilled chicken $8

      Grilled shrimp $9

    • Wells Farm Pig Roast

      Rum soaked pork, roasted pineapple teriyaki, coconut rice, mango salad, black beans

      $24

    • Tiki Tacos

      Ahi tuna, ginger lime marinade , corn tortilla, avocado & tamari cream

      $18

  • a close up of food
    Slide 1 of 7
  • a plate of food with a sandwich and a salad
    Slide 2 of 7
  • a plate of food with rice meat and vegetables
    Slide 3 of 7
  • a vase filled with flowers sitting on a plate
    Slide 4 of 7
  • a hand holding a glass of orange juice
    Slide 5 of 7
  • a person holding a cup
    Slide 6 of 7
  • a close up of a flower
    Slide 7 of 7

    • For all groups of 7 or more we host with a set menu. 

    Our menu includes a draft beer or wine, shared family style appetizers, and choice of entree. 

    Our kitchen can very easily accommodate for guests who are gluten free or have other allergies. We can tailor the menu to meet the needs of your party. 

    Price is typically $58 per person (plus 20% gratuity and taxes & fees) but fluctuates with depending on menu, party size, date etc. 


    This menu ensures everyone has an enjoyable experience. 

    Please email to reserve now!  GM@FirstAndSouth.com


    Below is an example of one of our menus

    Shared Family Appetizers

    Multiple portions of some of our favorite starters, served family style.

    • Shishito Peppers

      seared, citrus salt, old bay aioli

    • Kale Ceasar Salad

      baby kale, caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, apples, walnuts, croutons

    • Mushroom & Truffle Mac & Cheese

      mushrooms, truffle oil

    Choice of Entree

    Every selects their own entree from one of 4 choices. Typically our menus include one fish, steak, chicken, and vegetarian option. That way there is something for everyone!

    • Lobster Roll

      green goddess herb butter, lettuce, first fries

    • Petit Filet

      filet, au poivre, first fries

    • Fried Chicken Sandwich

      goat cheese ranch, applewood smoked bacon, first fries

    • Rice & Beet Salad

      wild rice, local roasted beets, sautéed spinach, fried chic peas, goat cheese, balsamic, cranberries

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!

    Reservations

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thanks!