A menu for everyone; comfort food, fresh salads, sandwiches, and daily specials highlighting our surrounding area & seasons
Soups, Salads & First Fries
South Street Chowder
our classic chowder; new england style, local clams, applewood smoked bacon, fresh herbs
Pint$13.50
gluten free
Greek Salad
red leaf lettuce, cucumber, tomato, red onion, mixed olives, red bell pepper, artichoke, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, herb vinaigrette, grilled naan
rotating selection of micro breweries & Guinness on tap
$6.75
Wines
prosecco, draft wine, montepulciano & pinot noir
$8.75
"Call" Drinks
two part mixers
$8.75
Signature Drinks
44N Huckleberry, Mules, Aperol Spritz, Dark & Stormy
$10.75
Happy Hour Snacks
Happy Hour Half Price Local Oysters
Always local, always fresh, not always this price point! :)
Half Dozen$14
Dozen$26
Happy Hour Wings
Our traditional cajun wing sauce, Point Reyes blue cheese & celery
$10
Happy Hour Mezze
hummus, olive tapenade, tzatziki, pita & crudités
$16
Happy Hour First Fries
Our triple blanched, hand cut fries, made with love
$7
On Mondays, all year-round, we offer a fantastic deal on beer mussels and first fries all day for just $19. Don't miss out on our happy hour from 3-5pm.
Lunch 12-5pm
Oysters on the Half Shell
OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH, ORIENT, NY - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
half dozen$22
dozen$39
Farm Frittata
North Fork Farm Fresh Eggs, seasonal vegetables & green salad
IPA +sweet chili glazed slow roasted pork, Otherside IPA BBQ ribs, apple & radish slaw with queso fresco & mint, yuzu cornbread & charred lemon butter, steamed rice, chili charred Latham's broccoli
$28
Join us on Tuesdays for a flavor-filled fiesta! Indulge in our mouthwatering handmade pupusas and tacos all day long. And don't forget about our incredible happy hour from 3-5pm. But the excitement doesn't stop there!
We have live music from 6-9pm to keep the party going. Come and experience a Tuesday at our restaurant!
crispy PECONIC GOLDS oysters, traditional coleslaw, scallion remoulade
$32
gluten free
LIVE MUSIC SCHEDULE
Sponsored by MORE GOOD TODAY
$1 per guest is donated every Tuesday for this
community-driven not-for-profit !!!
+ Live Music every first Friday & First Sunday of each month
Thursdays at our restaurant are a mini weekend getaway! Sip on our refreshing mai tai, savor our flavorful pad thai, and indulge in our sticky wings and tropical delights. Join us from 12-9pm as we take your taste buds on a delicious journey. Come hungry, leave happy!
Tropical Drinks
Mai-Tai
Aged Puerto Rican & light Barbados rums, Cointreau, Orgeat, mint
$16
Lunch
Oysters on the Half Shell
OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH, ORIENT, NY - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
crispy fluke, traditional coleslaw, malt vinegar aioli, First Fries
$34
Slide 1 of 4
Slide 2 of 4
Slide 3 of 4
Slide 4 of 4
Unwind, indulge, and savor! Start your weekend off right at our vibrant restaurant. With delectable lunch and dinner options available from 12-9pm, you can satisfy your cravings any time of the day. Get ready for a fantastic Happy Hour experience from 3-5pm on weekdays only, where you can enjoy irresistible deals and drinks that will keep your spirits high. Join us and let the good times roll!
TO GO FOOD - must be ordered before 6pm Fridays & Saturdays.
Lunch Specials
Oysters on the Half Shell
OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH, ORIENT, NY - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
Indulge in Saturday specials today! 🎉 Join us for lunch and dinner from 12-9pm to savor local favorites and our top-notch service. Don't miss out on our Butcher Block Specials for dinner!
Need your food to go? Remember to order before 6pm on Fridays and Saturdays.
Lunch Specials
Oysters on the Half Shell
OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH, ORIENT, NY - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion
crispy fluke, traditional coleslaw, malt vinegar aioli, First Fries
$34
To Share
Fresh Fruit
seasonal selection
$8.25
Pop Tart
handmade with LOVE, seasonal fruit filling
$6.15
Warm Biscuits
seasonal marmalade + seasonal butter
$6.75
Steakhouse Bacon
$8.25
Local Oysters
We are supplied with oysters from Yennicott/Southold, Peconic Gold/Peconic, Oysterpond Shellfish Co/Orient & Eel Town Oysters/Shelter Island.
half dozen$22
dozen$39
Oysters Rockefeller
Our version of this dish features pernod garlic cream, parmesan, goat cheese, spinach. Ordered by the half dozen these local oysters will come dressed & frozen ready to pop in the oven for guests. Garnish with a side a lemon.
lemongrass, garlic, white wine, saffron steeped shallots, cream, fines herbs, toasted baguette
$22
Mac & Cheese
Four cheese mornay sauce, garlic herb breadcrumbs (gf available +$10)
Half pan$65
Lunch
South Street Chowder
new england style, local clams, applewood smoked bacon, cream, fresh herbs
$13.50
gluten free
Greek Salad
red leaf lettuce, cucumber, tomato, red onion, mixed olives, red bell pepper, artichoke, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, herb vinaigrette, grilled naan
For all groups from 8 - 16 we host with a set menu for ease of service, guaranteeing the best experience for all guests on property. Whether a special occasion or just a few families gathering for a meal we can provide custom options, accommodate all allergies and ages.
Our menu includes a cocktail, shared family style appetizers, and choice of entree.
Our kitchen can very easily accommodate guests with any allergies or dietary restrictions. We can tailor the menu to meet the needs of your party.
Price is typically $92 per person (plus 20% gratuity and taxes & fees) but fluctuates depending on menu, party size, date, etc.
This menu ensures everyone has an enjoyable experience.
Please email to reserve now! GM@FirstAndSouth.com
Options for your custom menu are detailed below.
Shared Appetizers
Multiple portions of some of our favorite starters, served family style.
farm lettuces, cucumber, tomato, red onion, mixed olives, red bell pepper, artichoke, feta, stuffed grape leaves, herb vinaigrette, grilled naan
Choice of Entree
Every selects their own entree from one of 4 choices.
Typically our menus include one fish, steak, chicken, and vegetarian option.
That way there is something for everyone!
