100 South St, Greenport, NY 11944 (631) 333-2200
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating



Download PDF

Daily & Nightly Specials

...something to look forward to everyday!
  • Wednesday Wine Soireés

    Wednesday Wine Soireés

    The last Wednesday of every month we host a local vineyard...pair 3 or 4 wines with 3 or 4 farm fresh snacks & intimately host wine makers, farmers, oystermen, business owners, neighbors & friends. Join us!

    Guest $68

    Dining Club or Wine Club Member $58

  • Monday : Mussels & First Fries

    Monday : Mussels & First Fries

    Choose 1 of 3 ways to enjoy Prince Edward Island Mussels & First Fries

    Coconut Lemongrass $15

    Roasted Garlic & Saffron $15

    Chervil Garlic Butter $15

  • Tuesday : Pupusa's & Live Music (6-9)

    Tuesday : Pupusa's & Live Music (6-9)

    Handmade fresh every Tuesday! White corn taco shells & pupusas ; served with curtido, salsas & guacamole. Local artists share their talents from 6-9pm, check website for current artists!

  • Wednesday : Closed

    Wednesday : Closed

    The last Wednesday of every month we host a Wine Soiree...June 29th we'll be hosting McCall Vineyards ! To make a reservation please call 631-333-2200 or email GM@FirstandSouth.com

  • Thursday : Pad Thai Night aka Tiki Night

    Thursday : Pad Thai Night aka Tiki Night

    We pad thai all year & in summer we Tiki...stay tuned for more Asian inspired dishes & drinks

    Pad Thai; Traditional Thai noodle dish served with fried tofu $19

    add Chicken $9

    add Shrimp $11

  • Friday : Oyster Night

    Friday : Oyster Night

    Locally sourced from our neighboring farms...

  • Saturday Night : Butcher Block Specials

    Saturday Night : Butcher Block Specials

    Prime cut beef, lamb, pork & local fish. Check the daily specials for more details.

  • Sunday : Brunch 10am ~ 3pm

    Sunday : Brunch 10am ~ 3pm

    Handmade Bloody Mary's, Citrus Mimosas, classic brunch dishes & lunch all offered 10am-3pm every week.

text, letter

A menu of sturdy, comfort food highlighting our surrounding area & seasons. 

Start with soup and go from there...

  • South Street Chowder

    South Street Chowder

    Our classic chowder; littleneck clam, applewood smoked bacon, cream, potato

    Pint $13

    gluten free

  • Simple Arugula Salad

    parmesan, crispy shallots, spring onion vinaigrette

    $12

    dairy free, gluten free, vegetarian

  • Kale Caesar Salad

    Kale Caesar Salad

    baby kale, parmesan, toasted walnuts, apples, roasted garlic croutons (gf available)

    $16

  • Wedge Salad

    Iceberg lettuce, Rogue creamery "caveman" blue cheese, bacon lardons, tomato compote, pickled red onion, blue cheese dressing

    $18

    gluten free

  • Salad Additions

    Marinated Chicken $9

    Chilled Shrimp $11

    Fried Tofu $6

    Bacon Lardons $6

    Goat Cheese $4.50

  • Bread Service

    Baguette with house herb butter

    $5

  • First Fries

    First Fries

    hand cut, triple blanched idaho potatoes

    $10

    dairy free, gluten free, vegetarian

  • Cheese Fries

    Cheese Fries

    Housemade fries, all the cheese

    $15

    gluten free

  • Our House Made Sauces

    $2

    Chipotle Aioli

    "Caveman" Blue Cheese

    Goat Cheese Ranch

    Lemon Garlic Aioli

    Black Garlic Aioli

    Whole Grain Honey Mustard

    O.G Ketchup

    Tarragon Remoulade

    Cara Cara BBQ Sauce

    Wasabi Aioli

  • Mac & Cheese

    Mac & Cheese

    4 cheese mornay, garlic & herb breadcrumb (can be served gf)

    For One $16

    Add Cremini Mushroom & Truffle Oil $7

    Add Shrimp $11

    Add Chicken $9

    Add Sautéed Garlic Spinach $4

    Gluten Free Pasta $4

    Applewood Smoked Bacon Lardons $6

  • Shishito Peppers

    Shishito Peppers

    Seasoned tamari, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    $15

    dairy free, gluten free, vegetarian

  • Oysters Rockefeller

    Local oysters, Pernod garlic cream, spinach, parmesan & goat cheese

    3 for $18

    6 for $30

    gluten free

  • Lemon Pepper Shrimp

    Roasted garlic, parsley lemon butter, baguette

    $21

    Add pasta $5

  • Steamed Mussels

    Chervril garlic butter, white wine, baguette

    $19

  • Chicken Wings

    Baked & fried to order; Choose one way of three styles served with celery & carrot

    Cajun Buffalo & blue cheese dressing $18

    Dry Rub Ranch & goat cheese ranch dressing $18

    Chipotle dry rub & cara cara BBQ sauce $18

  • A Really Good Burger

    seasoned 8oz patty, First Fries, lettuce, and a pickle

    $16

  • Oyster Po' Boy

    Seasoned cornmeal crusted local oysters, shredded iceberg, tomato, pickle, tarragon remoulade, seasonal green salad (gf available)

    $24

  • Fried Chicken Sandwich

    Buttermilk brined chicken breast, hot sauce & honey, lettuce, tomato, pickle (gf available)

    $21

  • Black Bean Burger

    Black Bean Burger

    Roasted mixed peppers, avocado, queso fresco, carrot & cabbage slaw, chipotle aioli, seasonal side salad (gf available)

    $19

    dairy free, vegetarian

  • Ahi Tuna Burger

    Ahi Tuna Burger

    Grade A ground tuna, sesame cabbage slaw, wasabi aioli, pickled red onion, simple arugula salad (gf available)

    $24

    dairy free

  • Burger & Sandwich Additions

    Cheddar / Gruyere / Blue Cheese $3

    Tomato / Red Onion / Banana Peppers $2

    Crispy Fried Onion / Grilled Mushrooms / Grilled Onions $3

    Applewood Smoked Bacon $5

    Gluten Free Bun $4

    Avocado $4

  • Lobster & Shrimp Roll

    tarragon aioli, simple arugula salad

    $28

  • a bowl of food on a plate
    Slide 1 of 7
  • a close up of a sandwich sitting on top of a table
    Slide 2 of 7
  • a person holding a wine glass on a table
    Slide 3 of 7
  • a person sitting at a table with a plate of food
    Slide 4 of 7
  • a bowl of food on a table
    Slide 5 of 7
  • a chicken sandwich and fries on a plate
    Slide 6 of 7
  • a close up of a sandwich sitting on top of a wooden table
    Slide 7 of 7

    • Cocktails

    • Aperol Spritz

      prosecco, aperol, club soda, orange

      $11

    • Huckleberry Lemonade

      44 north huckleberry vodka, mint, house lemonade

      $14

    • Chai Old Fashioned

      Chai infused Redemption bourbon, simple syrup, angostura bitters

      $12

    • Margarita

      sliver tequila, fresh lime, agave, triple sec

      $14

    • Peach Iced Tea

      4 roses bourbon, peach nectar, fresh lemon, unsweetened tea

      $14

    • “The Mule”

      fresh lime, ginger beer texas: titos vodka smoked: el buho mezcal

      $14

    • Boris & Natasha

      rosé, figenza vodka, st. germain, fresh lemon, club soda

      $14

    • Mimosa

      oj, prosecco

      $11

    • Bloody Mary

      pickled vegetables, titos vodka, house mix

      $13

    • The Fancy

      LIV vanilla vodka, cold brew, chocolate, leopold brothers french press coffee liqueur, cream, fresh whip & a cherry on top

      $12

    • Dark and Stormy

      Ginger beer, Goslings rum, Lime

      $14

    Wine

    by the glass available but why stop there, buy a bottle

    • Prosecco, Ca’ De Doge

      Italy, NV

      Glass $11

      Bottle $42

    • Nicolas Idiart Rose

      France

      Glass $11

      Bottle $42

    • Cabaret Rose

      France

      Glass $12

      Bottle $40

    • Lenz Pinot Gris

      North Fork

      Glass $12

      Bottle $46

    • La Vite Pinot Grigio

      Sicily, Italy

      Glass $10

      Bottle $40

    • Calazul Albarino

      Rias Baixis, Spain

      Glass $12

      Bottle $46

    • Paddle Reef Sauvignon Blanc

      Marlborough, New Zealand

      Glass $12

      Bottle $46

    • Isla Sancerre

      Loire, France

      Glass $16

      Bottle $60

    • Raeburn Chardonnay

      Russian River Valley, CA

      Glass $14

      Bottle $54

    • Sannino Cabernet Franc

      North Fork

      Glass $12

      Bottle $46

    • Isla Grand Reserve

      Rhone Valley, France

      Glass $14

      Bottle $54

    • McCall Estate Merlot

      North Fork

      Glass $12

      Bottle $46

    • Matilda Nieves Mencia

      Galicia, Spain

      Glass $14

      Bottle $54

    • Pedroncelli Cabernet Sauvignon Blanch

      Sonoma County, CA

      Glass $14

      Bottle $48

    Beers

    • Miller Lite

      $5

    • Stella Artois

      $6

    • Allagash White

      $6

    • AleWife

      Death to Ego IPA or Thousand Stars Pilsner

      $8

    • Barrier Brewing Company

      Seasonal Fresh Can

      $8

    • Glutenberg Pale Ale

      Gluten Free

      $7

    • Clausthaler NA Beer

      $6

    • Austin East Orange Cider

      $6

    Soft Drinks…

    • Wicked Mint

      mint, lime bitters, grapefruit, simple syrup, club soda

      $6

    • Peach Punch

      black cherry, peach nectar, lemon, club soda

      $6

    • Mineral Water

      $6 per 750 ML

    • Coca-Cola

      $3

    • Diet Coke

      $3

    • Sprite

      $3

    • Gingerale

      $3

    • Unsweetened Iced Tea

      $3

    • Lemonade

      $3

    • Root Beer

      $4

    • Apple Juice

      $3

  • bar
    Slide 1 of 6
  • a cup of coffee on a table
    Slide 2 of 6
  • brunch
    Slide 3 of 6
  • a person holding a wine glass
    Slide 4 of 6
  • a glass of wine
    Slide 5 of 6
  • bourbon, rye cocktails
    Slide 6 of 6

    • Served 10:00 am to 3:00 pm 

    Brunch Favorites

    • Soup of the Day

      $10

    • South Street Chowder

      applewood smoked bacon, cream, fresh herbs

      $12

    • Simple Arugula Salad

      Spring onion vinaigrette, parmesan, crispy shallots

      $12

    • The Wedge

      rogue creamery caveman blue, bacon lardons, pickled red onion, tomato compote

      $18

    • Kale Caesar

      shaved parmesan, toasted walnut, sliced apple, garlic croutons

      $16

    • Add To Any Salad

      Grilled Chicken $9

      Chilled Shrimp $11

      Crispy Tofu $6

    • Burrata

      seasonal compote, prosciutto, arugula, toasted pistachio, grilled ciabatta

      $21

    • Lobster & Shrimp Roll

      tarragon aioli, butter toasted roll, simple arugula salad

    • Dubliner Burger

      jameson caramelized onion, dubliner cheddar, arugula, black garlic aioli, house ketchup, First fries

      $24

    • Black Bean Burger

      Roasted peppers, queso fresco, chipotle aioli, carrot & cabbage slaw, simple arugula salad

      $19

    • Warm Spiced Challah French Toast

      fresh berries, catskill maple syrup, chantilly cream

      $16

    • Acai Bowl

      banana, mixed berries, mango, chia seeds, coconut, gluten free granola

      $16

    • Farm Frittata

      seasonal ingredients, simple arugula salad

      $18

    • Fried Chicken & Buttermilk Biscuits

      country gravy, breakfast potatoes

      $21

      Add Poached Egg $3

    • Eggs Benedict

      english muffins, wilted spinach, poached eggs, old bay dusted hollandaise, breakfast potatoes with a choice...

      $24

      Fried Oysters $24

      Blackforest Ham $24

      Fried Green Tomato $24

    • Avocado Toast & Poached Egg

      beet hummus, arugula, blistered tomato

      $21

    • Smoked Salmon Plate

      garden vegetables, soft boiled egg, chive cream cheese, hummus, pickles, everything bagel chips

      $24

    To Share

    • Fresh Fruit

      seasonal selection

      $8

    • Pop Tart

      handmade with LOVE, seasonal fruit filling

      $7

    • Breakfast potatoes

      peppers, onion, scallion, roasted red bliss potatoes

      $6

    • Warm Croissants

      seasonal marmalade

      $5

    • First Fries

      hand cut, triple blanched, made with LOVE

      $10

    • Applewood Smoked Bacon

      $8

    • Breakfast Sausage

      $8

  • a bowl of food on a plate
    Slide 1 of 3
  • a cup of coffee on a table
    Slide 2 of 3
  • a close up of a plate of food on a wooden table
    Slide 3 of 3

    • All of our desserts are hand made & full of love. 

    • Oatmeal Pie

      Oatmeal Pie

      Sweet custard & brown sugar pie, fresh whip

      $10

    • Fruit Tart

      Fruit Tart

      Gluten Free crust, seasonal fruit, fresh whip

      $11

    • Brownie Sundae

      Brownie Sundae

      Tahini brownie bites (gf), toasted sesame, vanilla ice cream, caramel, chocolate sauce, fresh whip, amaro cherries

      $14

    • Bakewell Tart

      Strawberry & macadamia nut, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream

      $12

    • Buttermilk Pannacotta

      Apricot compote, candied orange

      $10

    • Peanut Butter Profiterole

      Peanut butter ice cream, chocolate sauce, peanut brittle

      $12

  • a plate of food on a table
    Slide 1 of 3
  • a person sitting at a table with a plate of food
    Slide 2 of 3
  • a person sitting at a table with a plate of food
    Slide 3 of 3

    • For the kids...

    Children 12 and under

    • A Really Small Burger

      4oz. Really Good Burger, slider bun, First Fries

      $14

    • Pasta

      served buttered or plain, parmesan by request

      $10

      Spinach $3

    • Grilled or Fried Chicken Breast

      served with First Fries

      $14

    • Fried Shrimp

      First Fries

      $14

    • Small Salad

      dressing of choice, lettuces, cucumbers, carrots, tomato

      $10

    For all groups of 7 or more we host with a set menu. 

    Our menu includes a draft beer or wine, shared family style appetizers, and choice of entree. 

    Our kitchen can very easily accommodate for guests who are gluten free or have other allergies. We can tailor the menu to meet the needs of your party. 

    Price is typically $58 per person (plus 20% gratuity and taxes & fees) but fluctuates depending on menu, party size, date etc. 


    This menu ensures everyone has an enjoyable experience. 

    Please email to reserve now!  GM@FirstAndSouth.com


    Below is an example of one of our menus

    Shared Family Appetizers

    Multiple portions of some of our favorite starters, served family style.

    • Shishito Peppers

      seared, citrus salt, old bay aioli

    • Kale Ceasar Salad

      baby kale, caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, apples, walnuts, croutons

    • Mushroom & Truffle Mac & Cheese

      mushrooms, truffle oil

    Choice of Entree

    Every selects their own entree from one of 4 choices. Typically our menus include one fish, steak, chicken, and vegetarian option. That way there is something for everyone!

    • Steamed Mussels

      Chervil garlic butter, white wine, fresh baguette

    • Petit Filet

      filet, au poivre, first fries

    • Fried Chicken Sandwich

      Buttermilk brined chicken breast, honey & hot sauce, lettuce, tomato, seasonal green salad

    • Pasta Pomodoro

      Blistered tomatoes, shaved garlic, wilted spinach, parmesan, toasted pine nuts

    Our new TO GO ROASTED CHICKEN DINNER to have at home! 

    Pre-Order begins Monday 631-333-2200 

    Pick up here @firstandsouth 

    Whole, natural roasted chicken with 

    Baby Kale Caesar Salad for Two 

    and

    Red Bliss Potato Salad for Two

    $34

     



    Pick up 2-4pm

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!

    Reservations

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thanks!