100 South St, Greenport, NY 11944 (631) 333-2200
100 South St, Greenport, NY 11944 (631) 333-2200
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Join us

Hey there! Looking for a spot to grab a bite? Swing by our restaurant for some delicious lunch and dinner options. We're open from 12-9pm on Monday, Tuesday, Friday, and Saturday. On Sundays, we've got a tasty brunch menu available from 10am-3pm (but no dinner service, sorry!). Just a heads up, we're closed on Wednesdays, and in September, we'll also be closed on Thursdays for private events. If you're interested in booking for an event, shoot us an email at GM@FirstandSouth.com. 

Book your First and South reservation on Resy

...for parties over 6ppl please email GM@FirstandSouth.com

Reservation and Cancellation Policy

  • Cancellation Window: You may amend or cancel your reservation up to 6 hours in advance.
  • Seating Requests: We will do our best to accommodate your seating preferences, taking into account weather conditions and other guests’ requests.
  • Stroller Parking: Strollers, walkers, scooters, and wagons can be parked in our designated driveway area. Please note that strollers cannot be accommodated inside the restaurant, but baby buckets are welcome. High chairs are available on the premises.
  • Allergies and Special Requests: If you have any severe allergies or special requirements, please include this information in your reservation.
  • Pet Policy: Friendly dogs are welcome in our outdoor areas, provided they are leashed. If you plan to bring your dog, please let us know in advance so we can ensure appropriate accommodations.

Thank you for your understanding and cooperation. We look forward to serving you!

Cheers!

Find your way...Greenport, NY

631-333-2200

Join us on Halloween between 4 - 7pm to participate (for free) in our community costume contest !!!

No theme to follow just pure creativity & fun!

How it works: 

1. Show up, dressed to impress

2. Sign in on the contest sheet for your professional photo to be taken for entry. (Name, costume, parent/consenting guardian email, or phone number. Teenagers 14 & over can participate with their own email if preferred

3. Wait your turn for the spooky stage to be set & ready for you…then smile, growl, wave, jump, whatever your costume conjures & snap ~ you’ve entered.

4. We will post all the photos (with consent) in our instagram stories for people to see & vote thru midnight.

5. The top 3 top costumes will be contacted & awarded gift certificates valued at $300 / $200 / $100 from First and South!!!

6. Post Halloween we will make your photos available to you for downloading.

👻 GHOUL LUCK EVERYBODY 🧟‍♂️

  • Slide 1 of 17
  • Slide 2 of 17
  • Slide 3 of 17
  • Slide 4 of 17
  • Slide 5 of 17
  • Slide 6 of 17
  • Slide 7 of 17
  • Slide 8 of 17
  • Slide 9 of 17
  • Slide 10 of 17
  • Slide 11 of 17
  • Slide 12 of 17
  • Slide 13 of 17
  • Slide 14 of 17
  • Slide 15 of 17
  • Slide 16 of 17
  • Slide 17 of 17

    • A menu for everyone; comfort food, fresh salads, sandwiches, and daily specials highlighting our surrounding area & seasons

    Soups, Salads & First Fries

    • South Street Chowder

      South Street Chowder

      our classic chowder; new england style, local clams, applewood smoked bacon, fresh herbs

      gluten free

    • Greek Salad

      mesclun greens, cucumber, tomato, red onion, kalamata olive, artichoke, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, herb vinaigrette, grilled naan

      vegetarian

    • Kale Caesar Salad

      curly kale, parmesan, toasted walnuts, apples, roasted garlic croutons (gf available)

    • First Street Wedge

      Point Reyes blue cheese crumble & dressing, baby iceberg, bacon lardons, pickled red onions, tomato compote, chives

      gluten free

    • Salad Additions

      roast chicken $12

      sautéed shrimp $12

      fried tofu $6

      seared salmon $14

      seared steak $16

    • First Fries

      hand cut, triple blanched, made with love

      dairy free, gluten free

    • Disco Fries

      gravy, queso, fresh herbs

    • Cheese Fries

      house-made fries, all the cheese

      gluten free

    • Our House Made Sauces

      chipotle aioli

      Point Reyes blue cheese

      goat cheese ranch

      lemon garlic aioli

      black garlic aioli

      whole grain honey mustard

      scallion remoulade

      wasabi aioli

      truffle aioli

      malt vinegar aioli

      cajun buffalo sauce

      russian dressing

    Sharing

    A few delectable items to get you & your company started

    • Local Oysters

      We are supplied with oysters from Yennicott/Southold, Peconic Gold/Peconic, Oysterpond Shellfish Co/Orient & Eel Town Oysters/Shelter Islands.

    • Oysters Rockefeller

      broiled local oysters, pernod garlic cream, spinach, parmesan, goat cheese

      gluten free

    • Saffron Mussels

      lemongrass, garlic, white wine, saffron steeped shallots, cream, fines herbs, toasted baguette

    • Burrata

      confit heirloom cherry tomatoes, garlic & shallots, basil pesto, warm baguette

    • Maple Carrots

      savory hummus, arugula, toasted pine nuts, water vinaigrette, black sea salt

      gluten free

    • Buffalo Wings

      cajun sauce, blue cheese, celery

      gluten free

    • Buttermilk Ranch Wings

      dry rub ranch spices & buttermilk powder, goat cheese ranch dressing, celery, carrots

      gluten free

    • Mac & Cheese

      Mac & Cheese

      4 cheese mornay, garlic & herb breadcrumbs (can be served gf)

      add cremini mushroom & truffle oil $7.25

      add roast chicken $12

      add sautéed garlic spinach $4.15

      gluten free pasta $4.12

      add applewood smoked bacon lardons $6.15

    • Mac & Cheese Additions

    Dinner

    Proper plates, various burgers & delicious sandwiches

    • Tuna Burger

      grade A house ground tuna, tamari glaze, cucumber, sesame cabbage slaw, wasabi aioli, pickled red onion, seasonal green salad

    • Black Bean Burger

      8oz house made bean burger, pan seared, queso fresco, chipotle cabbage slaw, guacamole, tomato, seasonal green salad

    • A Really Good Burger

      seasoned prime 8oz beef burger cooked to your temperature; lettuce, tomato, pickle, toasted potato bun, first fries

      dairy free

    • Fried Chicken Sandwich

      shredded cabbage, carrot & pickle slaw, russian dressing, sliced tomato, seasonal green salad (gf available)

    • Honey & Tangerine Salmon

      sautéed rainbow chard, shiitake, mushroom, lemon butter, garlic, shallots, scallions, jasmine rice

    • Roast Chicken

      mushroom bread pudding, marsala-caper sauce, seasonal roasted vegetables, toasted almonds

    • Steak Frites

      plancha grilled hanger steak, seasonal green salad, first fries, black garlic-merlot demi

      gluten free

    • Angel Hair Pomodoro

      blistered baby heirloom tomatoes, shaved garlic, wilted spinach, parmesan, toasted pine nuts (gf available)

      butter & herb shrimp $11.33

      roast chicken $9.27

    • Lemon Pepper Shrimp

      white wine garlic, parsley lemon butter, parmesan, fusilli pasta, baguette (gf available)

  • Slide 1 of 4
  • Slide 2 of 4
  • Slide 3 of 4
  • Slide 4 of 4

    • 3-5pm Weekdays Only

    Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday !!!


    HAPPY HOUR

    Weekdays 3-5pm food & drink specials

    • Draft Crafts

      rotating selection of micro breweries & Guinness on tap

      $6.75

    • Wines

      rosé, prosecco, muscadet, pinot grigio, montepulciano & pinot noir

      $8.75

    • "Call" Drinks

      two part mixers

      $8.75

    • Signature Drinks

      44N Huckleberry, Mules, Aperol Spritz, Dark & Stormy

      $10.75

    Happy Hour Snacks

    • Happy Hour Oysters

      Always local, always fresh, not always this price point! :)

      Half Dozen $14

      Dozen $26

    • Happy Hour Wings

      Our traditional cajun wing sauce, Point Reyes blue cheese & celery

      $10

    • Happy Hour Tzatziki

      served with pita & crudités

      $9

    • Happy Hour Olive Tapenade

      served with pita & crudités

      $9

    • Happy Hour Hummus

      house made with pita & crudités

      $9

    • Happy Hour First Fries

      Our triple blanched, hand cut fries, made with love

      $7

    On Mondays, all year-round, we offer a fantastic deal on beer mussels and first fries all day for just $19. Don't miss out on our happy hour from 3-5pm. 

    Lunch 12-5pm

    • Oysters on the Half Shell

      OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH CO., ORIENT - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Shishito Peppers

      lemon garlic aioli, tamari glaze, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    • Portobello Stack

      heirloom tomato, roasted red pepper, eggplant, arugula, basil pesto (nf), balsamic glaze, burrata, crispy garlic breadcrumbs (gf)

    • Monday Beer Mussels

      beer butter broth, farm leeks, cherry tomato, garlic + shallots, First Fries

    • Lobster & Shrimp Salad Sliders

      poached shrimp + knuckle, claw, tail lobster meat, lemon & tarragon aioli, arugula, toasted potato buns, First Fries

    • Fish & Chips

      crispy fluke, chipotle slaw, malt vinegar aioli, First Fries

    • B.L.L.T.

      steakhouse cider-glazed bacon, lettuce, smoked salmon lox, thick cut heirloom tomato, dill mayo, toasted sourdough, seasonal green salad

    Dinner 5-9pm

    • Oysters on the Half Shell

      OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH CO., ORIENT - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Shishito Peppers

      lemon garlic aioli, tamari glaze, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    • Portobello Stack

      heirloom tomato, roasted red pepper, eggplant, arugula, basil pesto (nf), balsamic glaze, burrata, crispy garlic breadcrumbs (gf)

    • Monday Beer Mussels

      beer butter broth, farm leeks, cherry tomato, garlic + shallots, First Fries

    • Lobster & Shrimp Sliders

      poached shrimp & knuckle, claw, tail lobster meat, lemon & tarragon aioli, arugula, toasted potato buns, First Fries

    • Fish & Chips

      crispy fluke, chipotle slaw, malt vinegar aioli, First Fries

    • Poke Bowl

      tamari tuna, red radish, scallion, sesame marinated cucumber, edamame, grilled pineapple, jasmine rice, togarashi mayo

      dairy free, gluten free

    Join us on Tuesdays for a flavor-filled fiesta! Indulge in our mouthwatering handmade pupusas and tacos all day long. And don't forget about our incredible happy hour from 3-5pm. But the excitement doesn't stop there! We have live music from 6-9pm to keep the party going. Come and experience a Tuesday at our restaurant!

    Lunch

    • Oysters on the Half Shell

      OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH CO., ORIENT - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Shishito Peppers

      lemon garlic aioli, tamari glaze, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    • Crispy Yucca Fries

      tajín spice, chipotle aioli

    • Handmade Pupusas

      mozzarella cheese, curtido slaw, pickled vegetable escabeche, tomato salsa, guacamole

      gluten free

    • Handmade Tacos

      cajun marinated fluke, pineapple pico, two hand presssed corn tortillas, salsa mojo & salsa verde, seasoned yucca fries

    • Lobster & Shrimp Salad Sliders

      poached shrimp + knuckle, claw, tail lobster meat, lemon & tarragon aioli, arugula, toasted potato buns, First Fries

    • East End Oyster Basket

      crispy EEL TOWN Oysters, Shelter Island, chipotle slaw, scallion remoulade, First Fries

      gluten free

    • Crispy Fish Sandwich

      local fish (gluten free breading), turnip + cucumber + cilantro slaw, beefsteak tomato, avocado herb sauce, seasonal green salad

    Dinner 5-10pm

    Live Music - not tonight, sorry!

    • Oysters on the Half Shell

      OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH CO., ORIENT - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Crispy Yucca Fries

      tajín spice, chipotle aioli

    • Shishito Peppers

      lemon garlic aioli, tamari glaze, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    • Portobello Stack

      heirloom tomato, roasted red pepper, eggplant, arugula, basil pesto (nf), balsamic glaze, burrata, crispy garlic breadcrumbs (gf)

    • Handmade Pupusas

      mozzarella cheese, curtido slaw, pickled vegetable escabeche, tomato salsa, guacamole

      gluten free

    • Handmade Tacos

      cajun marinated fluke, two hand pressed corn tortillas, shredded cabbage, pineapple pico, salsas roja & verde, seasoned yucca fries

    • Poke Bowl

      tamari tuna, red radish, scallion, sesame marinated cucumber, edamame, grilled pineapple, jasmine rice, togarashi mayo

      dairy free, gluten free

    • FRESH CATCH | FLUKE

      roasted cauliflower, turnip, Swiss chard, potato, shiitake mushrooms, garlic, shallot, lemon + caper brown butter

      gluten free

    LIVE MUSIC SCHEDULE

    Every Tuesday 6-9pm YEAR ROUND and the First Friday of every month

    We are excited to share that on Thursdays, during the fall and winter, we will be OPEN to serve you lunch and dinner from 12-9pm. And guess what? Starting at 5pm, we will be offering mouthwatering Pad Thai along with a selection of other delicious Polynesian style specials. But don't worry, our all-day menu will still be available for you to enjoy.

     Looking ahead, we have a special treat for all the dance enthusiasts out there! We will be hosting Blake Hobby Dowling's West Coast Swing in the evenings, while our dinner service continues. If you've always wanted to learn some classic dance moves from the best, meet amazing people, and have a delightful dinner with us, we encourage you to try something new. 

    For more information on the dancing event, please email Blake.hobby@hotmail.com. And as always, for restaurant reservations, simply proceed as usual. We can't wait to welcome you!

    Tropical Drinks

    • Mai-Tai

      Aged Puerto Rican & light Barbados rums, Cointreau, Orgeat, mint

    Lunch

    • Oysters on the Half

      Oysters on the Half

      OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH CO. - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion

      gluten free

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Roasted Carrot Soup

      coconut cream, chili oil, scallion, toasted pepitas

      dairy free, gluten free

    • Shishito Peppers

      lemon garlic aioli, tamari glaze, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    • Sticky Wings

      Korean bbq, asian slaw, toasted sesame & scallion

      dairy free, sesame

    • Lobster & Shrimp Salad Sliders

      poached shrimp + knuckle, claw, tail lobster meat, lemon & tarragon aioli, arugula, toasted potato buns, First Fries

    • East End Oyster Basket

      crispy EEL TOWN Oysters, Shelter Island, chipotle slaw, scallion remoulade, First Fries

      gluten free

    • Fish & Chips

      crispy fluke, chipotle slaw, malt vinegar aioli, First Fries

    Dinner

    • Local Oysters

      We are supplied with oysters from Yennicott/Southold, Peconic Gold/Peconic, Oysterpond Shellfish Co/Orient & Eel Town Oysters/Shelter Islands.

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Roasted Carrot Soup

      coconut cream, chili oil, scallion, toasted pepitas (gluten free & vegetarian)

      egg free, fish free, gluten free, peanut free, shellfish free, soy free, tree nut free

    • Sticky Wings

      Korean bbq, asian slaw, toasted sesame & scallion

      dairy free, sesame

    • Portobello Stack

      heirloom tomato, roasted red pepper, eggplant, arugula, basil pesto (nf), balsamic glaze, burrata, crispy garlic breadcrumbs (gf)

    • Lobster & Shrimp Salad Sliders

      poached shrimp + knuckle, claw, tail lobster meat, lemon & tarragon aioli, arugula, toasted potato buns, First Fries

    • Poke Bowl

      tamari tuna, red radish, scallion, sesame marinated cucumber, edamame, grilled pineapple, jasmine rice, togarashi mayo

      dairy free, gluten free

    • Pad Thai (after 5pm)

      Pad Thai (after 5pm)

      rice noodles, crispy tofu, cilantro, basil, toasted peanuts, crispy garlic, tamarind, sriracha

  • Slide 1 of 4
  • Slide 2 of 4
  • Slide 3 of 4
  • Slide 4 of 4

    • Unwind, indulge, and savor! Start your weekend off right at our vibrant restaurant. With delectable lunch and dinner options available from 12-9pm, you can satisfy your cravings any time of the day. Get ready for a fantastic Happy Hour experience from 3-5pm on weekdays only, where you can enjoy irresistible deals and drinks that will keep your spirits high. Join us and let the good times roll!

    Lunch Specials

    • Oysters on the Half Shell

      OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH CO., ORIENT - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Shishito Peppers

      lemon garlic aioli, tamari glaze, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    • Lobster & Shrimp Sliders

      poached shrimp & knuckle, claw, tail lobster meat, lemon & tarragon aioli, arugula, toasted potato buns, First Fries

    • B.L.L.T.

      steakhouse cider-glazed bacon, lettuce, smoked salmon lox, thick cut heirloom tomato, dill mayo, toasted sourdough, seasonal green salad

    • Oyster Basket

      crispy EEL TOWN oysters, chiptole slaw, scallion remoulade

      gluten free

    • Fish & Chips

      crispy fluke, chipotle slaw, malt vinegar aioli, First Fries

    Dinner Specials

    • Oysters on the Half Shell

      OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH CO., ORIENT - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Shishito Peppers

      lemon garlic aioli, tamari glaze, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    • Portobello Stack

      heirloom tomato, roasted red pepper, eggplant, arugula, basil pesto (nf), balsamic glaze, burrata, crispy garlic breadcrumbs (gf)

    • FRESH CATCH | FLUKE

      roasted cauliflower, turnip, Swiss chard, potato, shiitake mushrooms, garlic, shallot, lemon + caper brown butter

      gluten free

    • Poke Bowl

      tamari tuna, red radish, scallion, sesame marinated cucumber, edamame, grilled pineapple, jasmine rice, togarashi mayo

      dairy free, gluten free

    • Marinated Lamb Chops

      Mediterranean couscous, rosemary roasted baby carrots, mint pesto, toasted pine nuts

    BUTCHER BLOCK SPECIALS (Dinner only)

    Lunch & Dinner 12-9pm

    Lunch Specials

    • Oysters on the Half Shell

      OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH CO., ORIENT - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Shishito Peppers

      lemon garlic aioli, tamari glaze, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    • Lobster & Shrimp Sliders

      poached shrimp & knuckle, claw, tail lobster meat, lemon & tarragon aioli, arugula, toasted potato buns, First Fries

    • Crispy Fish Sandwich

      local fish (gluten free breading), turnip + cucumber + cilantro slaw, beefsteak tomato, avocado herb sauce, seasonal green salad

    • East End Oyster Basket

      crispy EEL TOWN Oysters, Shelter Island, chipotle slaw, scallion remoulade, First Fries

      gluten free

    • B.L.L.T.

      steakhouse cider-glazed bacon, lettuce, smoked salmon lox, thick cut heirloom tomato, dill mayo, toasted sourdough, seasonal green salad

    Dinner Specials

    Beginning at 5pm

    • Oysters on the Half Shell

      OYSTERPONDS SHELLFISH CO., ORIENT - cucumber aguachile, pickled red onion

    • Sourdough + Autumn Butter

      pumpkin spice + sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper

    • Shishito Peppers

      lemon garlic aioli, tamari glaze, toasted sesame, citrus zest

    • Portobello Stack

      heirloom tomato, roasted red pepper, eggplant, arugula, basil pesto (nf), balsamic glaze, burrata, crispy garlic breadcrumbs (gf)

    • Lobster & Shrimp Sliders

      poached shrimp & knuckle, claw, tail lobster meat, lemon & tarragon aioli, arugula, toasted potato buns, First Fries

    • FRESH CATCH | FLUKE

      roasted cauliflower, turnip, Swiss chard, potato, shiitake mushrooms, garlic, shallot, lemon + caper brown butter

      gluten free

    • Poke Bowl

      tamari tuna, red radish, scallion, sesame marinated cucumber, edamame, grilled pineapple, jasmine rice, togarashi mayo

      dairy free, gluten free

    • BUTCHER | BRAISED SHORT RIB

      yukon gold mashed potato, roasted broccoli, corn + mushrooms, crispy shallots, red wine reduction

      gluten free

    Served 10:00 am to 3:00 pm 

    Last Call at the bar 4:30pm

    Many of our lunch sandwiches & snacks are also available 

    Brunch Favorites

    • French Toast

      seasonal fruit, pure maple syrup, fresh whipped cream

    • Farm Frittata

      seasonal ingredients, green salad

    • Fried Chicken & Buttermilk Biscuit

      country gravy, breakfast potatoes

    • Eggs Benedict

      english muffins, wilted spinach, poached eggs, old bay dusted hollandaise, breakfast potatoes with a choice...

    • Brunch Burger

      truffle cheddar, red pepper aioli, sautéed mushroom, fried egg, pickle, First Fries

    • Steak & Eggs

      peppercorn crusted ribeye (prime & grass fed), 2 eggs any way, chive sour cream, crispy breakfast potatoes

    • Avocado Egg Salad Sandwich

      dill, parsley, cornichon, avocado, citrus, black sea salt, toasted sourdough, seasonal green salad

    • B.L.H.T.

      steakhouse cut cider-glazed bacon, lettuce, thick cut heirloom tomato, toasted sourdough, seasonal green salad

    To Share

    • Fresh Fruit

      seasonal selection

    • Pop Tart

      handmade with LOVE, seasonal fruit filling

    • Warm Biscuits

      seasonal marmalade + autumn butter

    • Steakhouse Bacon

    • Local Oysters

      We are supplied with oysters from Yennicott/Southold, Peconic Gold/Peconic, Oysterpond Shellfish Co/Orient & Eel Town Oysters/Shelter Islands.

    • Oysters Rockefeller

      Our version of this dish features pernod garlic cream, parmesan, goat cheese, spinach. Ordered by the half dozen these local oysters will come dressed & frozen ready to pop in the oven for guests. Garnish with a side a lemon.

    • Buffalo Wings

      cajun sauce, blue cheese, celery

      gluten free

    • Buttermilk Ranch Wings

      dry rub ranch spices & buttermilk powder, goat cheese ranch dressing, celery, carrots

      gluten free

    • Saffron Mussels

      lemongrass, garlic, white wine, saffron steeped shallots, cream, fines herbs, toasted baguette

    • Mac & Cheese

      Four cheese mornay sauce, garlic herb breadcrumbs (gf available +$10)

    • Portobello Stack

      heirloom tomato, roasted red pepper, eggplant, arugula, basil pesto (nf), balsamic glaze, burrata, crispy garlic breadcrumbs (gf)

    Lunch

    • South Street Chowder

      new england style, local clams, applewood smoked bacon, cream, fresh herbs

      gluten free

    • Roasted Carrot Soup

      coconut cream, chili oil, scallion, toasted pepitas

      dairy free, gluten free

    • Greek Salad

      mesclun greens, cucumber, tomato, red onion, kalamata olive, artichoke, feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, herb vinaigrette, grilled naan

    • Kale Caesar Salad

      curly kale, parmesan, toasted walnuts, apples, roasted garlic croutons (gf available)

    • First Street Wedge

      Point Reyes blue cheese crumble & dressing, baby iceberg, bacon lardons, pickled red onions, tomato compote, chives

      gluten free

    • Add To Any Salad

    • Lobster & Shrimp Salad Sliders

      poached shrimp + knuckle, claw, tail lobster meat, lemon & tarragon aioli, arugula, toasted potato buns, First Fries

    • Tuna Burger

      grade A house ground tuna, tamari glaze, cucumber, sesame cabbage slaw, wasabi aioli, pickled red onion, seasonal green salad

    • Fried Chicken Sandwich

      shredded cabbage, carrot & pickle slaw, russian dressing, sliced tomato, seasonal green salad (gf available)

    • Black Bean Burger

      8oz house made bean burger, pan seared, queso fresco, chipotle cabbage slaw, guacamole, tomato, seasonal green salad

    • Really Good Burger

      cheddar, steakhouse bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, served with first fries

    • Add to Your Burger

    • Crispy Fish Sandwich

      local fish (gluten free breading), turnip + cucumber + cilantro slaw, beefsteak tomato, avocado herb sauce, seasonal green salad

    • Oyster Basket

      crispy EEL TOWN oysters, chiptole slaw, scallion remoulade

      gluten free

  • Slide 1 of 4
  • Slide 2 of 4
  • Slide 3 of 4
  • Slide 4 of 4

    • Cocktails

    • Boris & Natasha

      rosé, Figenza vodka, St. Germain, fresh lemon, club soda

    • Yuzu Zuzu

      grey whale gin, yuzu, green tea, grapefruit

    • Chai Old Fashioned

      chai infused redemption rye whiskey, simple syrup, angostura bitters

    • Black Dirt Sangria

      Warwick Valley red wine, dark fruit port, ice & bubbles

    • Olvera Heist

      spicy silver tequila, pamplemousse, lime

    • Huckleberry Lemonade

      44 North Huckleberry vodka, mint, house lemonade

    • Mules

      fresh lime, ginger beer Texas: Tito’s vodka Smoked: siete misterios mezcal Summer Seasonal: cucumber & mint

    • Espresso Martini

      tito's vodka, oro gold espresso, kahlua, lemon

    • The Fancy

      vanilla vodka, cold brew coffee, chocolate, kahlua, cream agave

    • Mai Tai

      dark & light rums, orgeat, curaçao, fresh lime, crushed ice

    Wine

    by the glass or perhaps, a bottle?

    • Ca’del Doge Prosecco

      Italy

    • Sparkling Pointe Sparkling Brut NV

      Southold, NY

    • Rivarose Estate Sparkling Rosé Brut Prestige

      Provence, France

    • McCall Vineyards Rosé 2023

      North Fork, NY

    • Nicolas Idiart Rose

      France

    • Picpoul de Pinet 2021

      Chapelle du Bastion, France

    • La Vite Pinot Grigio

      Sicily, Italy

    • Hei Matau Sauvignon Blanc NV

      New Zealand

    • Donnafugata 'SUR SUR' Grillo 2020

      Sicily, Italy

    • Raeburn Chardonnay

      Russian River Valley, Sonoma County, California

    • Imagery Pinot Noir 2020

      Glen Ellen, California

    • Castorani Montepulciano

      Abruzzo, Italy

    • Macari 'SETTE' Merlot/Cabernet Franc NV

      North Fork, NY

    • Boomtown Cabernet Sauvignon 2020

      Columbia Valley, Washington

    • Wolffer Estate NA Sparkling Rosé

      Sagaponack, NY

    Wine

    buy the bottle

    • Antxiola Getariako Txakolina Blanco 2023

      Bodegas Zudugarai, Spain

    • Macari Vineyards Sauvignon Blanc 2023

      North Fork, New York

    • Perlinas Albarino

      Rias Biaxas, Spain

    • McCall Vineyards Cabernet Franc Reserve 2014

      Cutchogue, New York

    • Michael Guignier Gamay 2022

      Beaujolais, France

    • Pedroncelli Vineyards Sonoma Classico Red Blend 2021

      (merlot, syrah, sangiovese, zinfandel) Dry Creek Valley, CA

    • Turnbull Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon 2020

      Napa Valley, California

    Beers

    • Rotating Draft Beer

      three fresh kegs to choose from + Guinness Stout (m/p)

    • Fresh Cans

      our favorite breweries on rotation

    • Greenport Brewing Light Work Lager

    • Allagash White

    • North Fork Brewing Run the Juice

    • Barrier Brewing Lomax

    • Sand City Brewing Enough Already Already Sour

    • Miller Lite

    • Peroni

    • Doc's Cider

      gluten free

    • Ghostfish Meteor Shower

      gluten free

    • Best Day Brewing Kölsch

    • Partake Brewing IPA

      gluten free

    Mocktails

    • Peach Punch

      black cherry, peach nectar, lemon, club soda

    • Wicked Mint

      grapefruit juice, mint, simple, lime, club soda

    • Ginger Dream

      pineapple, ginger, lemon, club soda

    Soft Drinks…

    • Mineral Water

    • Coca-Cola

    • Diet Coke

    • Sprite

    • Gingerale

    • Unsweetened Iced Tea

    • Lemonade

    • Root Beer

    • Gosling’s Ginger Beer

    • Apple Juice

    • Orange Juice

    • Pineapple Juice

    • Tomato Juice

    • Iced Coffee

    • Chocolate Milk

    • Milk

    • Hot Cocoa

  • Slide 1 of 6
  • Slide 2 of 6
  • Slide 3 of 6
  • Slide 4 of 6
  • Slide 5 of 6
  • Slide 6 of 6

    • All of our desserts are hand made & full of love. 

    Desserts

    • Oatmeal Pie

      Oatmeal Pie

      sweet custard & brown sugar pie, fresh whip

    • Brown Butter Tart

      local peach, vanilla gelato, toasted almonds

    • Chocolate Almond Tart (GF)

      fresh whip, berries

    • Chocolate Soufflé Cake

      flourless chocolate cake, coffee toffee sauce, strawberries, fresh whip

    • Cinnamon Mascarpone Cheesecake

      caramel apple compote, graham cracker crust

    • Brownie Sundae

      Brownie Sundae

      tahini brownie bites (GF), toasted sesame, vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, fresh whip, amaro cherries

    • Lime & Coconut Cheesecake

      graham cracker crust, toasted coconut, blackberry sauce

    • Gelato

      choose from vanilla or chocolate

    • Sorbet

      lemon or mango

    • The Fancy a/k/a liquid dessert

      Tito's vodka, Griffo cold brew coffee liqueur, chocolate, Grady's cold brew, cream, agave

    • Espresso Martini

      tito's vodka, oro gold espresso, kahlua, lemon

  • Slide 1 of 3
  • Slide 2 of 3
  • Slide 3 of 3

    • For the kids...

    Children 12 and under

    • A Really Small Cheese Burger

      4oz. Really Good Burger, cheddar, slider bun, first fries

    • Pasta

      served plain or buttered

    • Chicken

      grilled OR fried chicken breast, served with first fries

    • Fried Shrimp

      first fries, lemon garlic aioli

    • Small Salad

      seasonal lettuce & vegetables, honey & lemon vinaigrette

    • Grilled Cheese

      first fries

    For all groups from 8 - 16 we host with a set menu for ease of service, guaranteeing the best experience for all guests on property. Whether a special occasion or just a few families gathering for a meal we can provide custom options, accommodate all allergies and ages.  

    Our menu includes a cocktail, shared family style appetizers, and choice of entree. 

    Our kitchen can very easily accommodate guests with any allergies or dietary restrictions. We can tailor the menu to meet the needs of your party. 

    Price is typically $92 per person (plus 20% gratuity and taxes & fees) but fluctuates depending on menu, party size, date, etc. 


    This menu ensures everyone has an enjoyable experience. 

    Please email to reserve now!  GM@FirstAndSouth.com


    Options for your custom menu are detailed below.

    Shared Appetizers

    Multiple portions of some of our favorite starters, served family style.

    • Kale Caesar Salad

      curly kale, parmesan, toasted walnuts, sliced apple, garlic croutons, caesar dressing

    • Mac & Cheese

      four cheese mornay, garlic & herb breadcrumb

    • First Fries

      hand cut, triple blanched, made with love

    • Buffalo Wings

      traditional cajun buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, carrot & celery

    • Crab Cakes

      charred pineapple slaw, garlic wilted spinach, pickled red onion, piquillo pepper yogurt

    • Burrata

      confit cherry tomatoes, garlic & shallots, basil pesto, radish sprouts, warm baguette

    • Roasted Beet Salad

      whipped goat cheese, toasted pistachio, balsamic glaze, pickled red onion, arugula & fennel

    Choice of Entree

    Every selects their own entree from one of 4 choices. Typically our menus include one fish, steak, chicken, and vegetarian option. That way there is something for everyone!

    • Angel Hair Pomodoro

      blistered baby heirloom tomato, shaved garlic, wilted spinach, parmesan, toasted pine nuts

    • Honey & Tangerine Salmon

      sautéed rainbow chard, shiitake mushrooms, lemon butter, garlic, shallots, scallions, jasmine rice

    • Lemon Pepper Shrimp

      white wine, garlic, parsley lemon butter, parmesan, fusilli pasta, baguette

    • Really Good Burger

      cheddar, steakhouse bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, served with first fries

    • Roast Chicken

      summer vegetable gratin, green & yellow wax beans, sweet corn tomato puree, gremolata

    • Black Bean Burger

      queso fresco, caramelized onion, guacamole, chipotle aioli, seasonal green salad

    • Steak Frites

      plancha grilled hanger steak, green salad, first fries, black garlic-merlot demi

    • Saffron Mussels

      lemongrass, garlic, white wine, saffron steeped shallots, cream, fines herbs, toasted baguette

    Email Signup

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thank you for signing up for email updates!
    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    Reservations

    Please check errors in the form above
    Thanks!
    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.