Reservations 2023

hello September!

Find your way...Greenport, NY

631-333-2200

Lunch & Dinner Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday & Saturday 12-9pm

Brunch on Sundays 10am-3pm (no dinner service)

Closed Wednesdays

Please call us at 631-333-2200 to reserve a table

South Street Chowder

our classic chowder; new england style, local clams, applewood smoked bacon, fresh herbs

Pint $13.39

gluten free
Roasted Beet Salad

arugula, toasted pistachios, blood orange, sumac-lime yogurt, horseradish zest

$18.54

gluten free

Roast chicken $9.27

Sautéed shrimp $11.33
Kale Caesar Salad

baby kale, parmesan, toasted walnuts, apples, roasted garlic croutons (gf available)

$16.48
Wedge Salad

Rogue Creamery "Caveman" blue cheese crumble & dressing, bacon lardons, pickled red onions, tomato compote

$18.54

gluten free
Salad Additions

roast chicken $9.27

sautéed shrimp $11.33

fried tofu $6.18

seared salmon $15.45
Bread Service

baguette with house herb butter

$5
First Fries

hand cut, blanched idaho potatoes

$10.30

dairy free, gluten free, vegetarian
Cheese Fries

house-made fries, all the cheese

$14.55

gluten free
Disco Fries

gravy, queso, fresh herbs

$17.25
Our House Made Sauces

$2.05

chipotle aioli

"Caveman" blue cheese

goat cheese ranch

lemon garlic aioli

black garlic aioli

whole grain honey mustard

tarragon remoulade

cara cara BBQ sauce

wasabi aioli
Mac & Cheese

4 cheese mornay, garlic & herb breadcrumbs (can be served gf)

For One $18.54

add cremini mushroom & truffle oil $7.21

add roast chicken $9.27

add sautéed garlic spinach $4.16

gluten free pasta $4.12

add applewood smoked bacon lardons $6.18
Oysters Rockefeller

broiled local oysters, pernod garlic cream, spinach, parmesan, goat cheese

3 for $18.54

6 for $30.90

gluten free
Autumn Burrata

roasted mushroom fricassee, black truffle, warm baguette, micro basil

$21.63
Za'atar-Spiced Carrots

cauliflower humus, frisée, feta, toasted pumpkin seeds, pumpkin seed oil

$16.48

gluten free
Saffron Mussels

lemongrass, garlic, white wine, saffron steeped shallots, cream, fines herbs, toasted baguette

$21.63
Buffalo Wings

traditional cajun buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, celery, carrots

$18.54

gluten free
Buttermilk Ranch Wings

dry rub ranch spices & buttermilk powder, goat cheese ranch dressing, celery, carrots

$18.54

gluten free
A Really Good Burger

seasoned 8oz patty, first fries, lettuce, tomato, pickle

$17.51

dairy free
Add to Your Burger

cheddar / gruyere / caramelized onions $3.09

steakhouse bacon $4.12

gluten free bun $4.12
Fried Chicken Sandwich

sliced pickles, gruyere, whole grain honey mustard, lettuce, tomato, red onion, seasonal green salad (gf available)

$24.72
Black Bean Burger

piquillio pepper pico, queso fresco, chipotle slaw, guacamole, seasonal green salad (gf available)

$21.63

dairy free, vegetarian
Tuna Burger

grade A house ground tuna, tamari glaze, cucumber, sesame cabbage slaw, wasabi aioli, pickled red onions, seasonal green salad (gf available)

$24.72

dairy free
Lemon Pepper Shrimp

white wine garlic, parsley lemon butter, parmesan, fusilli pasta, baguette

$27.81
Angel Hair Pomodoro (after 5pm)

blistered baby heirloom tomatoes, shaved garlic, wilted spinach, parmesan, toasted pine nuts (available after 5pm for dinner service)

$24.72

butter & herb shrimp $11.33

roast chicken $9.27
Plancha Grilled Hanger Steak (after 5pm)

parmesan potato galette, swiss chard, parsnips, black garlic-merlot sauce

$42.23

gluten free
Roast Chicken (after 5pm)

wild mushroom bread pudding, wilted spinach, charred onion, almonds, marsala-caper sauce

$28.84
Pastrami-Spiced Salmon (after 5pm)

celery root puree, swiss chard, blackened cauliflower, preserved lemon, roasted pepper tapenade

$32.96

Draft Crafts

rotating selection of micro breweries & Guinness on tap

$6.18
Wines

rosé, prosecco, muscadet, pinot grigio, montepulciano & pinot noir

$8.24
"Call" Drinks

two part mixers

$8.24
Signature Drinks

44N Huckleberry, Mules, Aperol Spritz, Dark & Stormy

$10.30
HH Oysters

6 for $12.36

12 for $24.72
First Fries

triple blanched, made with love

$6.18
HH Mac & Cheese

four cheese mornay, garlic herb breadcrumbs

$10.30
Buffalo Wings

cajun sauce, blue cheese, celery

$10.30

gluten free

Homemade Irish Cream

$24.72
Bloody Mary Guts

$15.45
EATDRINKPLAY ~ WHOLE BEAN COFFEE

Mexican fair trade beans roasted weekly by HAVE A NICE DAY COFFEE

$15.45
First & South Coffee Mug

$17.30
Holiday Ornament

Artist Kelly Franké's line drawing of the corner of First and South on porcelain circle with gold ribbon

$15.45
First & South Greenport Wear

Black Short Sleeve $22.66

Green Long Sleeve $25.75

Crop Top $22.66

Red Kids Sweatshirt $39.14

Black Pullover Hoodie $46.35

Blue Zip-Up Hoodie $59.14

Oysters on the Half Shell

YENNICOTT OYSTERS, SOUTHOLD apple ginger-yuzu mignonette, lemon
Firecracker Clams

four broiled local top neck clams, trim-color pepper butter, applewood smoked bacon
Beer Cheese

tomatoes, peppers, cilantro, butter-brushed pretzel bites
Crispy Shrimp Salad

cabbage, mixed greens, cucumbers, pickled red onions, banana peppers, avocado, garlic croutons, lemon vinaigrette
Monday Mussels

fennel, roasted red peppers, cherry tomatoes, shallots, garlic, Killsborough Brewing Killsner, First Fries

gluten free
B.L.T.G.

cider glazed thick cut bacon, hot house tomato, shredded iceberg, house-made guacamole, toasted sourdough, green salad

Oysters on the Half Shell

YENNICOTT OYSTERS, SOUTHOLD apple ginger-yuzu mignonette, lemon
Firecracker Clams

four broiled local top neck clams, trim-color pepper butter, applewood smoked bacon
Beer Cheese

tomatoes, peppers, cilantro, butter-brushed pretzel bites
Crispy Shrimp Salad

cabbage, mixed greens, cucumbers, pickled red onions, banana peppers, avocado, garlic croutons, lemon vinaigrette
Monday Mussels

fennel, roasted red peppers, cherry tomatoes, shallots, garlic, Killsborough Brewing Killsner, First Fries

gluten free
Sautéed Blackfish

jasmine rice, cherry tomatoes, cauliflower, capers, toasted almonds, roasted pepper pico

Oysters on the Half Shell

YENNICOTT OYSTERS, SOUTHOLD apple ginger-yuzu mignonette, lemon
Firecracker Clams

four broiled local top neck clams, trim-color pepper butter, applewood smoked bacon
Chicken Tortilla Soup

housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish

gluten free
Handmade Pupusas

mozzarella cheese, curtido slaw, pickled vegetable escabeche, tomato salsa, guacamole
House Tacos

two handmade corn tortillas, spicy mango pico, guacamole, salsas roja & verde, seasoned yucca fries
Crispy Oyster Salad

cabbage, mixed greens, cucumbers, pickled red onions, banana peppers, avocado, garlic croutons, lemon vinaigrette

Oysters on the Half Shell

YENNICOTT OYSTERS, SOUTHOLD apple ginger-yuzu mignonette, lemon
Chicken Tortilla Soup

housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish

gluten free
Handmade Pupusas

mozzarella cheese, curtido slaw, pickled vegetable escabeche, tomato salsa, guacamole
House Tacos

two handmade corn tortillas, spicy mango pico, guacamole, salsas roja & verde, seasoned yucca fries

12/5 Rob Europe

6-9pm
12/12 Julia King

6-9pm
12/19 Jeff LeBlanc

6-9pm
12/26 Jeff LeBlanc

6-9pm
1/9 Julia King

6-9pm

Chicken Tortilla Soup

housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish

gluten free
Sticky Wings

chipotle-honey-sesame, crispy garlic, cilantro, sesame slaw
B.L.T.G.

cider glazed thick cut bacon, hot house tomato, shredded iceberg, house-made guacamole, toasted sourdough, green salad

Gingered Squash Soup

Blue Hubbard squash, Evercrisp apple, bourbon cream, toasted almonds
Sticky Wings

chipotle-honey-sesame, crispy garlic, cilantro, sesame slaw
Pan Roasted Brussels Sprouts

citrus-sumac yogurt, dried cranberries, toasted walnuts, squash oil
Blackened Tofu Salad

mixed greens, cabbage, cucumber, avocado, banana peppers, basil, toasted peanuts, lemon vinaigrette
Pad Thai (after 5pm)

rice noodles, crispy tofu, cilantro, basil, toasted peanuts, crispy garlic, tamarind, sriracha
Mahi Mahi

jasmine rice, cherry tomatoes, fennel, chorizo, lemon brown butter, roasted red pepper pico

Oysters on the Half Shell

YENNICOTT OYSTERS, SOUTHOLD apple ginger-yuzu mignonette, lemon
Roasted Oysters

local pepper pico (spicy), garlic breadcrumbs, feta, chives

gluten free
Chicken Tortilla Soup

housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish

gluten free
Pan Roasted Brussels Sprouts

citrus-sumac yogurt, dried cranberries, toasted walnuts, squash oil
Blackened Shrimp Salad

cabbage, mixed greens, cucumbers, pickled red onions, banana peppers, avocado, bean sprouts, basil, cilantro, peanuts, lemon vinaigrette
B.L.T.G.

cider glazed thick cut bacon, hot house tomato, shredded iceberg, house-made guacamole, toasted sourdough, green salad

Oysters on the Half Shell

YENNICOTT OYSTERS, SOUTHOLD apple ginger-yuzu mignonette, lemon
Roasted Oysters

local pepper pico (spicy), garlic breadcrumbs, feta, chives

gluten free
Chicken Tortilla Soup

housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish

gluten free
Pan Roasted Brussels Sprouts

citrus-sumac yogurt, dried cranberries, toasted walnuts, squash oil
Crispy Oyster Salad

cabbage, mixed greens, cucumbers, pickled red onions, banana peppers, avocado, garlic croutons, lemon vinaigrette
Sautéed Blackfish

jasmine rice, cherry tomatoes, cauliflower, capers, toasted almonds, roasted pepper pico
Merlot Braised Short Rib

yukon gold potato puree, charred brussels sprouts, roasted mushrooms, black garlic-merlot sauce

Oysters on the Half Shell

YENNICOTT OYSTERS, SOUTHOLD apple ginger-yuzu mignonette, lemon
Roasted Oysters

local pepper pico (spicy), garlic breadcrumbs, feta, chives

gluten free
Chicken Tortilla Soup

housemade chicken broth, chiles guajillo & poblano, tomato, cilantro, thyme, queso fresco, avocado, radish

gluten free
Pan Roasted Brussels Sprouts

citrus-sumac yogurt, dried cranberries, toasted walnuts, squash oil
Crispy Oyster Salad

cabbage, mixed greens, cucumbers, pickled red onions, banana peppers, avocado, garlic croutons, lemon vinaigrette
Sautéed Blackfish

jasmine rice, cherry tomatoes, cauliflower, capers, toasted almonds, roasted pepper pico
Merlot Braised Short Rib

yukon gold potato puree, charred brussels sprouts, roasted mushrooms, black garlic-merlot sauce

South Street Chowder

new england style, local clams, applewood smoked bacon, cream, fresh herbs
Oyster Rockefeller

broiled local oysters, pernod garlic cream, parmesan, goat cheese, spinach
Roasted Beet Salad

arugula, toasted pistachios, blood orange, sumac-lime yogurt, horseradish zest

gluten free
The Wedge

rogue creamery caveman blue cheese crumbles, bacon lardons, pickled red onions, tomato compote, blue cheese dressing
Kale Caesar

baby spinach, shaved parmesan, toasted walnuts, sliced apples, garlic croutons
Add To Any Salad
Autumn Burrata

roasted mushroom fricassee, black truffle, warm baguette, micro basil
Za'atar-Spiced Carrots

cauliflower humus, frisée, feta, toasted pumpkin seeds, pumpkin seed oil

gluten free
Buffalo Wings

traditional cajun buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, celery, carrots

gluten free
First Fries for Two

hand cut, blanched with LOVE
Black Bean Burger

piquillio pepper pico, queso fresco, lettuce, chipotle slaw, guacamole, seasonal green salad
French Toast

seasonal fruit, pure maple syrup, chantilly cream
Farm Frittata

seasonal ingredients, green salad
Fried Chicken & Buttermilk Biscuit

country gravy, breakfast potatoes
Eggs Benedict

english muffins, wilted spinach, poached eggs, old bay dusted hollandaise, breakfast potatoes with a choice...
Tuna Burger

grade A house ground tuna, tamari glaze, cucumber, sesame cabbage slaw, wasabi aioli, pickled red onion, seasonal green salad
Black Bean Burger

piquillio pepper pico, chipotle slaw, guacamole, queso fresco, seasonal green salad
Crispy Fish Sandwich

cornmeal dusted local fluke, lettuce, pickles, pickled red onions, potato bun, First Fries

Fresh Fruit

seasonal selection
Pop Tart

handmade with LOVE, seasonal fruit filling
Breakfast potatoes

peppers, onions, scallions, roasted red bliss potatoes
Warm Biscuits

seasonal marmalade
Steakhouse Bacon

Jumpseat

bergamot tea-infused cognac, sage, rosemary, lemon
Bitter End

blended scotch, sweet vermouth, gran classico, green chartreuse
Boris & Natasha

rosé, Figenza vodka, St. Germain, fresh lemon, club soda
Yuzu Zuzu

gin, yuzu, green tea, grapefruit
Chai Old Fashioned

chai infused whiskey, simple syrup, angostura bitters
Huckleberry Lemonade

44 North Huckleberry vodka, mint, house lemonade
Harvest

house cider, bourbon, honey; served hot or cold
Martinez

old tom gin, sweet vermouth, maraschinos
Mules

fresh lime, ginger beer Texas: Tito’s vodka Smoked: Del Maguey Vida mezcal Mediterranean: Figenza vodka Seasonal: cinnamon-infused tequila, peach
Espresso Martini

tito's vodka, oro gold espresso, kahlua, lemon
Hot Buttered Rum

buttered rum, coco Lopez, allspice dram, whipped cream
The Fancy

vanilla vodka, cold brew coffee, chocolate, kahlua, cream agave

Ca’del Doge Prosecco

Italy
Nicolas Idiart Rose

France
McCall Estate Marjorie's Rosé

North Fork, NY
Jadix Picpoul de Pinet 2021

France
La Vite Pinot Grigio

Sicily, Italy
One Woman, Gruner Veltliner 2020

North Fork, New York
Licence IV Muscadet Blanc NV

Loire Valley, France
Raeburn Chardonnay

Russian River Valley, Sonoma County, California
Imagery Pinot Noir 2020

Glen Ellen, California
Castorani Montepulciano

Abruzzo, Italy
McCall Estate Merlot

North Fork
True Myth Cabernet Sauvignon

Paso Robles, California

Natures Revenge Pétillant Naturel 2021

Languedoc Roussillon, France
Sparkling Pointe Brut Seduction 2012

North Fork, New York
Casa Emma Rosé 2022

Tuscany, Italy
Les Lauzeraies Rosé 2022

Tavel, France
Domaine Reverdy-Ducroux Sancerre 2022

Loire Valley, France
Weingut Forsteiter Grüner Veltliner 2021

Kremstal Kogl, Austria
Rene Sequin-Colin Borgogne Aligote 2021

Burgundy, France
Wolffer Estate Pinot Gris 2021

Sagaponack, New York
Donnafugata Sur Sur Grillo 2021

Sicily, Italy
Morey Domaine Coffinet Pinot Noir 2021

Cote-D'OR Burgundy, France
Domaine de la Charmoise Gamay 2018

Loire Valley, France
Wolffer Estate Cabernet Franc 2019

Sagaponach, New York
McCall Vineyards Cabernet Franc Reserve 2014

Cutchogue, New York
Fattoria Montecchio "PRISCUS" Super Tuscan 2016

Tuscany, Italy
Domaine Santa Duc 'Les Quatre Terres' Cotes Du Rhone 2021

Rhone Valley, France
Paumanok Vineyards 'Assemblage' Bordeaux Blend 2015

Aquebogue, New York
Turnbull Wine Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon 2020

Napa Valley, California

Rotating Draft Beer

three fresh kegs to choose from + Guinness Stout (m/p)
Fresh Cans

our favorite breweries on rotation
Barrier Brewing x First & South 'North Road' Kölsch
North Fork Brewing Run the Juice
Other Half Green City Dry-Hopped IPA
Talea Fruited Sour
Barrier Brewing The Carver
Allagash White
Barrier Oktoberfest
Ghostfish Meteor Shower
Miller Lite
Peroni
Austin’s East Orange Cider (GF)
Athletic Brewing Upside Dawn

Mineral Water
Coca-Cola
Diet Coke
Sprite
Gingerale
Unsweetened Iced Tea
Lemonade
Root Beer
Gosling’s Ginger Beer
Apple Juice
Orange Juice
Pineapple Juice
Tomato Juice
Iced Coffee
Chocolate Milk
Milk
Hot Cocoa

Oatmeal Pie

sweet custard & brown sugar pie, fresh whip
Chocolate Almond Tart (GF)

fresh whip, berries
Caramel Apple Cheesecake

salted caramel sauce, apple compote
Roasted Banana Cae

vanilla gelato, salted caramel sauce, toasted coconut
Brownie Sundae

tahini brownie bites (GF), toasted sesame, vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, fresh whip, amaro cherries
Gelato

choose from vanilla, chocolate, or pumpkin spice
Lemon Sorbet
The Fancy a/k/a liquid dessert

Tito's vodka, Griffo cold brew coffee liqueur, chocolate, Grady's cold brew, cream, agave

A Really Small Cheese Burger

4oz. Really Good Burger, cheddar, slider bun, first fries
Pasta

served plain or buttered
Chicken

grilled OR fried chicken breast, served with first fries
Fried Shrimp

first fries, lemon garlic aioli
Small Salad

seasonal lettuce & vegetables, honey & lemon vinaigrette
Grilled Cheese

first fries

For all groups from 8 - 16 we host with a set menu for ease of service, guaranteeing the best experience for all guests on property. Whether a special occasion or just a few families gathering for a meal we can provide custom options, accommodate all allergies and ages.

Our menu includes a cocktail, shared family style appetizers, and choice of entree.

Our kitchen can very easily accommodate guests with any allergies or dietary restrictions. We can tailor the menu to meet the needs of your party.

Price is typically $82 per person (plus 20% gratuity and taxes & fees) but fluctuates depending on menu, party size, date, etc.

This menu ensures everyone has an enjoyable experience.

Please email to reserve now! GM@FirstAndSouth.com

Below is an example of one of our menus

Kale Caesar Salad

baby kale, parmesan, toasted walnuts, sliced apple, garlic croutons, caesar dressing
Mac & Cheese

four cheese mornay, garlic & herb breadcrumb
First Fries

hand cut, triple blanched, made with love
Buffalo Wings

traditional cajun buffalo sauce, blue cheese dressing, carrot & celery
Crab Cakes

charred pineapple slaw, garlic wilted spinach, pickled red onion, piquillo pepper yogurt
(large group)

roasted mushroom fricassee, black truffle, warm baguette, micro basil
(large group)

arugula, toasted pistachios, blood orange, sumac-lime yogurt, horseradish zest

Angel Hair Pomodoro

blistered baby heirloom tomato, shaved garlic, wilted spinach, parmesan, toasted pine nut
(large group)

celery root puree, swiss chard, blackened cauliflower, preserved lemon, roasted pepper tapenade
Lemon Pepper Shrimp

white wine, garlic, parsley lemon butter, parmesan, fusilli pasta, baguette
Really Good Burger

cheddar, cider glazed bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion, served with first fries
(large group)

wild mushroom bread pudding, wilted spinach, charred onion, almonds, marsala-caper sauce
Black Bean Burger

piquillio pepper pico, chipotle slaw, guacamole, queso fresco, seasonal green salad
(large group)

parmesan potato galette, swiss chard, parsnips, black garlic-merlot sauce
(large group)

lemongrass, garlic, white wine, saffron steeped shallots, cream, fines herbs, toasted baguette

Reservations 2023

631-333-2200

Start with soup and go from there...

HAPPY HOUR

To Go Specialty Items & Gear

Lunch 12-5pm

Dinner 5-9pm

Lunch 12-5pm

Dinner 5-9pm

LIVE MUSIC SCHEDULE

Lunch

HAPPY HOUR

Dinner

Lunch Specials

Dinner Specials

Lunch Specials

Dinner Specials

Brunch Favorites

To Share

Cocktails

Wine

Wine

Beers

Mocktails

Soft Drinks…

Desserts

For the kids...

Shared Appetizers

Choice of Entree

Reservations 2023

631-333-2200

Start with soup and go from there...

HAPPY HOUR

To Go Specialty Items & Gear

Lunch 12-5pm

Dinner 5-9pm

Lunch 12-5pm

Dinner 5-9pm

LIVE MUSIC SCHEDULE

Lunch

HAPPY HOUR

Dinner

Lunch Specials

Dinner Specials

Lunch Specials

Dinner Specials

Brunch Favorites

To Share

Cocktails

Wine

Wine

Beers

Mocktails

Soft Drinks…

Desserts

For the kids...

Shared Appetizers

Choice of Entree

Email Signup

Reservations