All Day Menu
A menu for everyone; comfort food, fresh salads, sandwiches, and daily specials highlighting our surrounding area & seasons. Check per day for our specials menu.
Please note, First and South will be closed for Winter Break from February 23 to March 16, 2026. We will reopen on Saint Patrick’s Day, March 17, 2026, from 12pm to 8pm. Join us then for a festive celebration.
Soups, Salads & First Fries
-
South Street Chowder
our classic chowder; new england style, local clams, applewood smoked bacon, fresh herbs
Pint $14
gluten free
-
Caesar
baby romaine, parmesan, roasted garlic crouton (gf available)
$16
-
Roasted Beet Salad
whipped feta, mixed greens, toasted almonds, sweet citrus vinaigrette, black sea salt
$18
-
First Street Wedge
Point Reyes blue cheese crumble & dressing, baby iceberg, bacon lardons, pickled red onions, tomato compote, chives
$22
gluten free
-
Salad Additions
roast chicken $12
sautéed shrimp $12
fried tofu $6
seared salmon $14
seared steak $16
-
First Fries
hand cut, triple blanched, made with love
$10.25
dairy free, gluten free
-
Our House Made Sauces
$2.25
chipotle aioli
Point Reyes blue cheese
goat cheese ranch
lemon garlic aioli
black garlic aioli
scallion remoulade
wasabi aioli
truffle aioli
malt vinegar aioli
cajun buffalo sauce
bbq sauce
Sharing
A few delectable items to get you & your company started-
Local Oysters
We are supplied with oysters from Yennicott/Southold, Peconic Gold/Peconic, Oysterpond Shellfish Co/Orient & Eel Town Oysters/Shelter Island.
half dozen $22
dozen $39
-
Oysters Rockefeller
broiled local oysters, pernod garlic cream, spinach, parmesan, goat cheese
3 for $19
6 for $31
gluten free
-
Sourdough + Seasonal Butter
sage + black sea salt + cracked black pepper
small $6
large $9
-
Burrata
roasted butternut squash, shaved radicchio, toasted pecans, bacon lardon, balsamic, warm baguette
$19
-
Mezze Plate
cucumber, tomato, feta salad, herb vinaigrette, mixed olives, tzatziki, hummus, red leaf lettuce, bell peppers, stuffed grape leaves, grilled naan
$24
vegetarian
-
Saffron Mussels
lemongrass, garlic, white wine, saffron steeped shallots, cream, fines herbs, toasted baguette
$23
-
Buffalo Wings
cajun sauce, blue cheese, celery
$19
gluten free
-
Buttermilk Ranch Wings
dry rub ranch spices & buttermilk powder, goat cheese ranch dressing, celery, carrots
$21
gluten free
-
Mac & Cheese
4 cheese mornay, garlic & herb breadcrumbs (can be served gf)
For One $19
add cremini mushroom & truffle oil $7.25
add roast chicken $12
add sautéed garlic spinach $4.15
gluten free pasta $4.12
add applewood smoked bacon lardons $6.15
-
Mac & Cheese Additions
cremini mushroom & truffle oil $7
sautéed garlic spinach $4
applewood smoked bacon lardons $6
roast chicken $12
Dinner
Proper plates, various burgers & delicious sandwiches-
Tuna Burger
grade A house ground tuna, tamari glaze, cucumber, sesame cabbage & pickled red onion slaw, wasabi aioli, seasonal green salad
$28
-
Black Bean Burger
pan seared 8oz house made bean burger, queso fresco, sautéed mushrooms, crispy fried onions, black garlic aioli, seasonal green salad
$23
-
A Really Good Burger
seasoned prime 8oz beef burger cooked to your temperature; lettuce, tomato, pickle, toasted potato bun, first fries
$17.50
dairy free
-
Fried Chicken Sandwich
shredded cabbage, carrot & pickle slaw, bbq sauce, seasonal green salad (gf available)
$24
-
Honey Miso Salmon
sautéed bok choy, shiitake mushroom, sweet tamari, garlic, shallots, scallions, jasmine rice
$34
-
Poke Bowl
tamari tuna, seared brussels sprouts, avocado, edamame, pickled carrots, radish & ginger salad, sesame, cucumber, crispy garlic & chili, jasmine rice, togarashi mayo
$34
dairy free, gluten free
-
Roast Chicken
roasted butternut squash, shallot & cauliflower, creamed kale, lemon mustard sauce, toasted almonds
$30
-
Seared Angus Steak
8oz skirt steak, horseradish creme fraiche, roasted root vegetables, rosemary fingerling potatoes
$44
gluten free
-
Pasta Pomodoro
blistered baby heirloom tomatoes, shaved garlic, wilted spinach, garganelli, parmesan, toasted pine nuts (gf available)
$25
butter & herb shrimp $11.33
roast chicken $9.27
-
Lemon Pepper Shrimp
white wine garlic, parsley lemon butter, parmesan, linguine, (gf available)
$32
Seasonal Sides
(Dinner only)-
Creamed Kale
$12
-
Rosemary Fingerlings
$9
-
Roasted Root Vegetables
$12
-
Tomato, Cucumber & Feta Salad
$9
-
Sautéed Spinach
$12
-
Jasmine Rice
$6